Judge Mathis Says Diddy Should Receive First-Time Offender Treatment In Sentencing

Judge Greg Mathis has weighed in on Sean “Diddy” Combs’ federal trial verdict, offering a candid and measured response to the hip-hop mogul’s conviction.

Speaking from Mountain Gate Golf Course on Wednesday, Mathis shared his thoughts on the outcome and what should come next. His stance is clear: Diddy must face the same sentencing standards as any other defendant would under similar circumstances.

Combs, once one of music’s most untouchable figures, avoided conviction on the weightiest charges—racketeering and sex trafficking. Mathis said he never believed the federal racketeering charge fit the facts and described the sex trafficking counts as questionable.

Yet, he expressed deep sympathy for Cassie Ventura and the other women who testified to enduring abuse at Diddy’s hands. The former television judge made it clear that accountability must follow.

Diddy was found guilty on two counts tied to prostitution under the Mann Act, which involve transporting individuals for illegal sexual activity across state lines. Mathis urged Judge Arun Subramanian, who will oversee sentencing, to impose a term within the federal guidelines. As a first-time offender, Mathis said Combs should serve between 21 and 27 months. Anything less, in his view, would fall short of justice.

Mathis acknowledged uncertainty about whether Diddy’s continued detention was necessary to protect society or the witnesses who took the stand. Still, he admitted concern that without meaningful consequences, the artist might repeat harmful patterns. He bluntly noted that unless Combs receives intervention or rehabilitation, “he’s going to do it again.”

The former Detroit judge also addressed widespread criticism that federal prosecutors overreached with the racketeering charge. He agreed that the RICO case never seemed solid but pointed out that overcharging is a strategy often used by the government to force plea deals or secure convictions on lesser counts. Mathis explained that this approach, while controversial, reflects a long-standing federal playbook.

Beyond the courtroom, Mathis spoke about speculation that Combs might seek a presidential pardon, possibly from Donald Trump if he wins reelection. He called the idea unlikely but not impossible, given the unpredictability of politics and celebrity influence.

Mathis also offered a sharp critique of those in the entertainment world who waited until after the verdict to voice their views. In his eyes, silence during the trial spoke volumes about loyalty and fear in the industry.

As Combs awaits sentencing at Brooklyn’s Metropolitan Detention Center, Mathis’ words serve as a reminder that even icons must answer to the law. The path forward will reveal whether justice, accountability, and rehabilitation can coexist in a case that has gripped both hip-hop and the nation.